The 24 hours create my game can be done with a normal dual shock, just plug it in your system so it cant run out of battery.As for the 24 hours create my game did not freeze at all. I don't think you can do this with a normal dual shock controller either but bnecker717 may be able to tell you more. Bnecker717 used a turbo controller and I used a turbo fight stick in which allowed the pop up to open and close consistently. I'll send bnecker717 a message and ask them to reply back as well as they might have more information then I do.
Put a tip of your joint, or a normal piece of paper, left or right of the left controller stick so you are making circles.
Just leave the game 24 hours in create my game.. and voila the trophy is yours.
You can also do it at night if you want to play during the day, it will add up the time you spend in there.